b) The early church believers were
      mainly Jews who knew the Law and all its ordinances which 
      they observed and most probably continued to observe until, so to speak,
      they were told not to. 
      So, it is possible that they continued observing the law of tithing (like,
      for example, they continued 
      going to the temple daily to pray), since they did not consider themselves
      as if they embraced 
      another religion, but only that some of the prophecies of their own Jewish
      religion, concerning 
      Messiah, were being fulfilled.
      
      Jesus mentioned tithing only once (Mat. 23:23, Luke 11:42)
      where He approved of it. It must be 
      born in mind that He referred to the Jews, and that at that time, the New
      Testament was not in 
      force as yet. On the other hand, apostle Paul, even when writing about the
      support of those who 
      are called to preach the gospel (the New Testament "Levites" - so to speak),
      does not mention 
      tithing. Admittedly, he does call on to the Old Testament (1 Cor. 9:8) but
      in verse 9 he refers to 
      something other than the law of tithing.
       
      There is an interesting passage in the book of Acts:
       
	
	   | 
	    
	    Acts 2:46 "So continuing daily with one accord in the
	    temple, and BREAKING BREAD 
	    from house to house, THEY ATE THEIR FOOD WITH GLADNESS AND SIMPLICITY 
	    OF HEART." | 
	 
       
      
        
      Could the above be the practice of tithing according to
      the book of Deuteronomy? It may or may 
      not be the case.
       
      I would like to draw your attention to another verse in
      the Old Testament:
       
	
	   | 
	    
	    Deu. 12:8-9 (God's commandment to the Israelites) "You
	    shall not at all do as we are doing 
	    here today - every man doing whatever is right in his own eyes - for as yet
	    you have not 
	    come to the rest and the inheritance which the Lord your God is giving
	    you." | 
	 
       
      
        
      We, the New Testament believers, are often referred to
      as the "Joshua Generation", i.e.. those 
      who have entered the "rest and the inheritance". This would imply that we
      are not expected to do, 
      and therefore not to teach, every man according to what is right in his own
      eyes, but rather 
      according to God's commandments.
       
      So, my advise remains: if you believe that tithing is
      valid for the New Testament church - go for it. 
      I have shown you from the word of God what tithing is. If you believe that
      the New Testament 
      giving is the matter of the heart - go for it. In absence of the clear leading
      by the Holy Spirit, you 
      may use the law of tithing as a guide when setting up your level of giving
      for the support of those 
      who minister to you spiritually, and to those who are in need, without neglecting
      some fun with 
      your own family.
       
      
      If we look back to the Old Testament and tithing we will
      see that God was the One who separated 
      Levites for Himself - and He provided for them EXACTLY the amount they needed
      to have a 
      comparable standard of living with the rest of the Israelites. Today, it
      is God who calls people into 
      His ministry and it is He who brings people to salvation, i.e.. to each
      particular church. If anyone 
      claims that we need more than one-third of 10% of our income today, to support
      those in the 
      ministry, he is saying that God has lost the account of His people. Well,
      I would argue that one. 
      He knows EXACTLY whom He has called to preach and He knows
      EXACTLY whom He has 
      saved. If we have overproduced the "ministers" it is our fault. In the time
      of Nehemiah they 
      checked the genealogy of those who claimed to be Levites before they were
      allowed to minister 
      (Neh. 7).  | 
      |